Selecting out the worst performer amongst President Donald Trump’s Cupboard appointees is a troublesome job — it’s a aggressive race, in any case — however one member who deserves to be within the operating by nearly any measure of incompetence is Sean Duffy, the secretary of Transportation.
Duffy is a basic instance of somebody who is aware of who’s answerable for the screw-ups on his watch, and it’s by no means him.
He has spent the final weeks and months blaming the Biden administration for quite a few operational failures in our air site visitors system since he took over. These embrace the Jan. 29 midair collision over Washington, D.C., that price 67 air passengers their lives, in addition to a number of near-misses on the bottom.
Some Trump Cupboard members have extra essential portfolios than Duffy — Homeland Safety Secretary Kristi Noem and Protection Secretary Pete Hegseth, neither of whom has displayed something approaching primary competence at their job, come instantly to thoughts.
However the American public is certain to be significantly delicate to the functioning of our transportation infrastructure. That’s very true in relation to the security and reliability of air journey; each flight delay and safety-related mishap hits American vacationers within the intestine.
The very best-profile failure (up to now) is the catastrophe named Newark Liberty Worldwide Airport, the place flight delays can final for the higher a part of a day and questions on security are rife.
Duffy, a former actuality present contestant and four-term congressman, involves the blame recreation with soiled palms. Let’s have a look.
First, right here’s what he’s stated concerning the situation of Federal Aviation Administration operations and staffing.
“I believe it’s clear that the blame belongs with the final administration,” he said Monday throughout a information convention at Division of Transportation headquarters. “Pete Buttigieg and Joe Biden did nothing to repair the system that they knew was damaged.” He stated, “Throughout COVID, when individuals weren’t flying? That was a perfect time to fix these problems.”
A few factors are pertinent right here. First, in 2019, when Duffy was a Republican member of Congress from Wisconsin, the invoice to fund the Division of Transportation amongst different businesses got here earlier than the Home. Duffy voted against it. So did 179 different members of the GOP caucus; 12 Republicans joined the Democrats to cross the measure.
Second, the pandemic 12 months during which “individuals weren’t flying” was 2020. That 12 months, the home passenger rely plummeted to 369.4 million from 926.7 million the earlier 12 months. It was the bottom determine since 1984.
Who was president in 2020? Not Biden, however Donald Trump.
After 2020, passenger masses crept again up, reaching 666.2 million in 2021 and persevering with increased to the document of 982.7 million final 12 months. If there was a chance to improve the air site visitors system in any case inconvenience to passengers, it was 2020. However nothing was performed then, on Trump’s watch.
I requested the DOT final week if Duffy may reconcile these evidently deceptive and inconsistent statements. I’m nonetheless ready for a reply.
Duffy has maintained that it’s nonetheless protected to fly out and in of Newark, regardless of outages throughout which air site visitors controllers’ screens went black and radios went silent — for 30 seconds on April 28 and 90 seconds on Could 9. A backup system failed at the airport May 11 for 45 minutes, inflicting delays and cancellations for lots of of flights.
Duffy admitted to the right-wing radio host David Webb on Could 12 that he had switched his spouse’s flight reservation for the following day from Newark to LaGuardia airport. He subsequently defined that he didn’t say to take action as a result of he thought Newark was unsafe, however to spare her a protracted delay. In different phrases, he had discovered an answer for his household, however not for the general touring public, which didn’t converse effectively for his administration of the mess at Newark.
It’s correct to notice that the FAA has been in an operational funk for years. Duffy can attempt to blame Biden, however that’s a smoke display screen. Throughout Trump’s first time period, when the FAA’s issues have been well-known, hiring and deployment of air site visitors controllers truly shrank from the extent throughout the Obama administration, according to the DOT’s inspector general, to the purpose the place staffing “couldn’t preserve tempo with attrition.”
Within the first finances he submitted after taking workplace in 2017, Trump proposed slashing the DOT finances by 13%. The finances plan referred to as for cutting 30,000 workers from the FAA staff.
The issues date again even additional — at the very least to 1981, when Ronald Reagan fired 11,000 air site visitors controllers at a single blow to interrupt their union. A frenzy of hiring and coaching adopted, however the alternative cohort has handed its retirement age. The FAA is presently about 3,000 controllers shy of its goal staffing, so the individuals on the job are stretched to their breaking level.
It isn’t as if Trump and Duffy pulled out all of the stops to repair the FAA’s persistent issues upon taking workplace. Some 3,000 “probationary” staff on the company have been fired throughout a DOGE rampage, in keeping with a count by the Professional Aviation Safety Specialists, the union representing security and technical employees on the FAA, and an announcement by Rep. Steve Womack, R-Ark., chair of the subcommittee overseeing the Transportation Division finances. The probationary firings and two subsequent rounds of buyouts will carry staffing on the DOT down by 12% since Trump took workplace.
Throughout appearances final week earlier than the Home and Senate appropriations committees, Duffy boasted about saving taxpayers practically $10 billion throughout the first 100 days of the Trump administration. That provoked Womack to riposte, “I believe we must be a bit of bit extra exact in downsizing a division with a mission as crucial as DOT’s. … The query is fairly easy: What number of departures are you able to deal with with out eroding the flexibility to hold out a protected and efficient mission?”
“We are able to do extra with much less, Mr. Chairman,” Duffy replied. When employees settle for buyout gives to retire or resign, he stated, “we should always take them up on that. … If I’ve individuals who don’t need to be there, let’s get some individuals in who’re hungry to do the work.” Certainly, after the primary spherical of firings on the FAA, Division of Authorities Effectivity boss Elon Musk issued a public attraction that air site visitors controllers who had “retired, however are open to returning to work, please consider doing so.”
Moreover, Trump’s freeze on disbursement of funds from Biden’s Infrastructure Funding and Jobs Act and Inflation Discount Act encompassed modernization projects at airports nationwide.
Musk’s fingerprints have been additionally on the resignation of FAA Administrator Michael Whitaker, a former airline government and former FAA deputy administrator who had been unanimously confirmed to a five-year time period in October 2023. Whitaker resigned as of Jan. 20 after clashing with Musk over the FAA’s oversight of SpaceX, which Musk owns.
Trump has nominated Republic Airways Chief Government Bryan Bedford as his alternative, however Bedford hasn’t been confirmed.
Throughout his Senate appropriations committee testimony on Thursday, Duffy maintained that his finances cuts and firings hadn’t compromised security in any respect. He particularly denied that any air site visitors controllers had been fired or provided buyouts.
Sadly for Duffy, Sen. Patty Murray, D-Wash., a lawmaker whose gentle demeanor masks her behavior of coming to a debate with arduous info in hand, was within the room. She listed for Duffy all of the steps he had taken that had prompted “unacceptable chaos” within the air transport system.
Since Jan. 20, she stated, “just about each greenback and transportation undertaking has been held up sooner or later. You’re inflicting a site visitors jam, from freezing funding for initiatives to creating new hurdles by reevaluating grants that had already been accredited, including crimson tape by forcing unacceptable political calls for on state and native transportation businesses, and outright canceling and chopping grants. … No prior Transportation secretary has lower funding for beforehand awarded grants on this method.”
As for Duffy’s blaming the Biden administration “for completely all the pieces,” Murray continued, “the final administration didn’t make the choice to carry up hundreds of grants, had nothing to do with the brand new crimson tape that you’ve created, and definitely didn’t let go of lots of of employees to assist get these grants out the door.”
Turning to Duffy’s assertion that no air site visitors controllers had been fired or purchased out, Murray instructed him, “Whilst you speak about modernizing the air site visitors management system, you have got pressured out greater than 2,000 FAA staff who help these air site visitors controllers — the technicians, the mechanics, the engineers, the IT specialists on the FAA who have been engaged on modernization.”
Duffy, certainly, stepped on his personal arguments. He complained that the Biden administration had saddled him with some 3,200 contracts that had been awarded however wanted to be signed. However he acknowledged that he needed to undergo these contracts to eradicate provisions he thought smacked of “wasteful DEI and local weather necessities.” These are ideological shibboleths and not at all “wasteful,” since DOT initiatives have manifest results on the welfare of residents within the communities the place they’re constructed or deliberate and on local weather change itself.
Because it occurs, on April 24, Duffy despatched a letter to all recipients of DOT funds — successfully just about each state and hundreds of native jurisdictions, warning them that pursuing “DEI objectives … violates federal legislation.” He threatened explicitly to withhold DOT funding from jurisdictions that fail to cooperate with federal immigration authorities. That is the “crimson tape” that Murray referenced.
Whether or not DEI applications and failures to cooperate with federal immigration roundups actually violate federal legislation, as Duffy asserted, just isn’t remotely a settled authorized query, however the matter is earlier than federal judges throughout the land. The truth that Duffy is losing his time by making these threats and brushing via awarded contracts to ferret out such putative violations is, nonetheless, a settled query: After all he’s.
It might not be lengthy now earlier than Duffy’s ideological vetting of transportation contracts and his decimation of the working employees on the FAA trigger even larger disruptions within the air and on land, probably with deadly penalties. His efforts accountable everybody else for his personal failures are certain to have a really quick half-life. Elevate your tray tables and your reclining seats, and fasten your seat belts. We could also be coming in for a tough touchdown.
©2025 Los Angeles Instances. Go to at latimes.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
