COMMENT: Once I ask somebody about your theories, they declare you might be unconventional. They stated the identical factor about Einstein and even Kynes within the early Nineteen Twenties. Plainly anybody who thinks outdoors the field is labeled unconventional, however in the long run, they undertake the very theories and develop into standard. They appear to make historical past repeat, for they all the time defend their place, which is clearly fallacious.
I simply needed to say that historic recurrence just isn’t one thing new. It has performed an essential function in growing Western historiography since antiquity. I’m positive you might be nicely versed. The view that “historical past repeats itself” is characteristically Greek. They understood every part was cyclical from the observations of cosmic and social cycles. I consider you have got defined that historical past repeats itself higher than anybody. It’s human nature for folks to reply the identical method to comparable conditions whatever the century.
Your intention to carry a WEC for the subsequent era is important. You might be providing one thing academia will solely acknowledge when they’re pressured into embarrassment as to put through the Nice Melancholy. Solely then did they flip to Keynes.
There are these of us prepared to donate to such a undertaking.
Please contemplate the significance of this for the subsequent era.
Paul
ANSWER: Historical past repeats as a result of human nature is fixed whatever the century. However it’s usually additionally pushed by notions of retribution, rebirth, reenactment, and imitation. Each Hitler and Napoleon sought to resurrect the previous Roman Empire. As a result of I witnessed the debasement of silver coinage in 1965 and was aware of the debasement of Roman coinage and the way they, too silver, plated bronze coinage to retain the looks of silver as we created a nickel-clad coinage in 1965, as a child, I immediately noticed historical past repeating.
Here’s a Roman coin of Marius (268AD). You’ll be able to see that the silver plating is beginning to put on off, revealing the core is merely bronze. Inflation was hovering, and President Kennedy signed an govt order to take away silver from the coinage in 1963. Right here, we see in Rome that inflation additionally soared as soon as emperor Valerian I (253-260AD) was captured in battle by the Persians – the primary emperor to have even been captured. That additionally set in movement a monetary panic the place bankers had been unsure if they need to even settle for Roman cash anymore.
By the center of the second century BC, Rome, Polybius of Megalopolis, had written his Historiae to clarify how Rome conquered the recognized world. These thirty-nine books acquired their finality after 146BC. At first, Polybius was excited by Greek affairs. He was surprised by the rise of Rome and its speedy growth into an empire. He tried what he would name common historical past fairly than simply taking a look at Rome as a neighborhood aberration or fluke. His Anacyclōsis supplied primary paradigms of historic recurrence that had been beneath the floor. Certainly, Polybius established that finding out historical past offered sound political coaching (cf. Hist. I, I,2).
Polybius’s well-known dialogue of the blended character of Rome’s republican structure is present in E-book 6, chap. 5. It was actually Polybius who presupposed that previous occasions mirrored varied paradigmatic actions and patterns that would reemerge in present and future affairs. Plainly the Darkish Ages, which noticed the demise of data and impartial thought in Europe, additionally altered our understanding of the world and cycles.
They burned Giordano Bruno (1548–1600) alive on the stake for merely agreeing with Calpurnicus in suggesting that the Earth rotated across the solar. The stupidity of the closed-minded at the moment noticed Haven have to be above and Hell was beneath, so if the Earth was not fastened, then all faith was fallacious. Thus, burn him alive as a heretic.
I enormously recognize the provide. We are going to do one thing like that, for I shouldn’t have the time to jot down a plan for college students.
